I'd like to hear views on the melody writing question for the leaving cert. I feel the marking scheme is pretty vague and subjective. I've seen recalled leaving cert questions receiving 20/40 marks where there is little wrong with the structure or sound. Any one else have an isssue here?
Have this issue all the time. I feel it's all down to the correctors "taste"... I've seen some that deserve good marks receive low marks and some that are "safe" receive the same mark. The marking schemes should not allow for this vagueness!