Guide

How to succeed in your Junior Cycle Music CBA 1

By John Casey - 11 minute read

This guide written by music teacher John gives you everything you need to know about how to succeed in your Junior Cycle Music CBA 1.

Jump to:

Show all sections

Introduction

The new Junior Cycle music course allows you to display your creativity in the two CBAs that you have to complete:

  • CBA 1 in 2nd year

  • CBA 2 in 3rd year  

Your CBAs do NOT form part of your overall music exam result and are graded differently. The result or descriptor you achieve appears separately on your Junior Cycle Profile of Achievement. They are awarded by your class teacher in consultation with other music teachers in your school or from schools in the surrounding area.

Descriptors

The official definitions of the descriptors awarded are as follows:

Exceptional

The student communicates eloquently and confidently. They display a comprehensive knowledge of the topic with a very well-structured presentation. The support material chosen displays creativity and is used very effectively to captivate the audience. The student’s reflections on the topic are of excellent quality, demonstrating clearly how the student’s point of view has developed or evolved over time.

Above expectations

The student communicates clearly, competently and with confidence. They display a very good knowledge of the topic with a well-structured presentation. The support material chosen interests the audience, displaying some creativity. The student’s reflections on the topic are of very good quality.

In line with expectations

The student communicates well. They display a good knowledge of the topic but lack some confidence, with the presentation unclear in places. The support material chosen is appropriate but not used to its full potential. The student displays an ability to reflect on their own perspective of the topic.

Yet to meet expectations

The student does not communicate clearly or confidently. They display a very limited knowledge of the topic and the presentation lacks structure. The support material chosen is used in a basic manner and the student’s reflections on the topic are narrow and of poor quality.

Remember

The award you get for your CBA does NOT affect your exam grade. They are in addition and appear separately on your JCPA as evidence of additional work done with the standard achieved in that additional work.

This guide will look at what you need to do to successfully complete and score highly in your CBA I: Composition Portfolio.

Timing

CBA I will take place over the duration of your second year in school. It is designed to be a project that develops your composing skills bit by bit so that, towards the end of year two, you will have completed a variety of composing tasks. 

From this, you then choose two pieces of work you wish to submit as your composition portfolio.

Top tip

Don’t feel pressure about having to create a 'masterpiece'.

Common questions

The objective of the CBA is to develop your creativity in line with your musical knowledge. You need to be able to present this in a clear way so that another performer could recreate the sound as you intended. This is why your presentation is just as important as the creativity you show. 

The CBA I task is deliberately designed to be approached in an open-ended and varied way. It is hoped that all music students will approach it differently and embark on their own personal composing journey. As there is no set structure, the best way to examine it is in a question-and-answer (Q&A) format:

What is examined?

Your overall descriptor will be based on your teacher's assessment. This assessment takes three elements into account:

  • Your creativity

  • Your presentation

  • Your reflection on your own learning throughout the process

How will my CBA be marked?

As outlined earlier, you will be awarded a descriptor according to how well your teacher deems your work to be (in consultation with others).

Teachers are asked to consider the following Features of Quality when grading CBA I. To score highly, you need to make sure your composition portfolio displays the following elements:

  • Evidence of highly developed melodic, rhythmic or harmonic concepts.

  • These melodic, rhythmic, harmonic concepts are developed in a skillful and sophisticated way.

  • The compositions are highly original and imaginative.

  • A high understanding of instrument use is evident.

  • A high understanding of the appropriateness and use of effects is evident.

  • The use of instruments and effects is suitable for the medium or genre of music presented.

  • The pieces have a very clear purpose.

  • The pieces are fully realised for their intended audience.

What can I include in my portfolio?

Any project in which you had creative input can be included. The following are some examples but this list is not exhaustive so don’t feel limited to it. You could:

  • adapt or add accompaniment or an ostinato to an existing piece or song;
  • create an advertisement/jingle/sonic branding for a real or imaginary product;
  • create a 'soundscape' by recording various natural or man-made sounds and then bring them together using a software package that allows you to record and edit;
  • write your own song/piece using instruments, voices or any available sound source;
  • create a piece of music from 'found sounds';
  • create a song/piece in response to a story/poem/incident, etc.

Do I have to do it on my own?

You can do it all on your own but you don’t have to. You can create as part of a group as large or as small as you like. You then pick the best two and that becomes your portfolio.

Top Tip

If you do create as part of a group, it is very important that you highlight your own work and how this contributed to the overall piece.

What if I don’t play an instrument or don’t play one well?

This is not an issue! The performance level does not matter. What's important is the creativity displayed, the presentation level and your own input and reflection on that input.

There are a lot of software packages out there that allow for the creation of music using a computer. These are perfectly acceptable as a medium for composition. Similarly, recording your own sounds and editing them in programmes such as Bandlab, Logic, or Audacity is also equally acceptable. Composing on an instrument is not the only way.

Top Tip

Programmes such as Bandlab where you can use pre-recorded loops are perfectly acceptable as a medium for composition.

I’ve never composed before. Where do I start?

Your music teacher will more than likely have a lot of ideas to get you started. Remember that this is a skill you are going to develop throughout the year so don’t get disheartened at the start if things seem difficult. Start small and build your confidence. Try the following steps to get you going and grow your confidence:

  • 1

    Choose a song or piece of music that you like.

  • 2

    Try adding a part to it (arranging/re-arranging) and build on that bit by bit.

  • 3

    Once you are comfortable with this method it becomes easy to progress and create your own original music.

  • 4

    Now, instead of using someone else's composition, make up your own rhythm or tune.

  • 5

    Add to it in the same way you did with an existing idea at the beginning of your composing journey.

  • 6

    Your creation of an original melody and accompaniment should now be taking shape.

How long do my compositions have to be?

There are no set guidelines for the length or complexity of the pieces you have to include. What's important is that they show originality, development of ideas, appropriate presentation and thoughtful reflection on your creative process. A one-minute piece that shows evidence of all these elements will score higher than a five-minute piece that does not.

Do I have to perform/record my pieces?

No, you don’t. If you don’t play an instrument or feel that you can’t play well enough, you can get someone else to perform your pieces and record them playing your compositions.

There are many ways to present your compositions as we will see later. Notating them using traditional notation or graphic notation, without a recording, is equally valid and will not affect your overall descriptor award.

How do I present my portfolio?

Once you have decided which two pieces to submit, the next step is to decide what way you wish to present it. The 'past masters' used only written means simply because that was the only one available to them.

Top Tip

There is no 'correct' way to present your portfolio.

You have a variety of ways available to you and all are equally valid. Pick the presentation style or combination of styles that you are most comfortable with and which you feel will showcase your work in the best possible way for the listener.

Your CBA I in music allows for an array of presentation methods depending on your own compositional style. You can present your portfolio in the following ways or indeed in any combination of these:

  • Visual presentation

    You can present your findings in any visual manner by using posters, displays, pictures, film or video. This could include a video of a performance or of you describing the two pieces. 

  • Written presentation

    The compositions can be presented in any written format. For example, a traditional handwritten project or music score. 

  • Audio presentation

    The composition portfolio can be presented as a recording. This could include you presenting a talk, a radio show or an interview in a podcast style. 

  • Digital presentation

    The CBA can be presented as a PowerPoint (or slideshow), a video/short film, a Padlet, or any other digital format.

It is important to show evidence of learning, evidence of that learning being applied in a practical way and evidence of creativity. You also need to make sure that what you write in the 'reflection on your learning' section is clear and presented in detail.

Remember

You will not be marked differently for the manner in which you present your portfolio.

Is it just my compositions that have to be included in my portfolio?

No. You must also include the statement, 'reflection on your learning'. This is an opportunity for you to highlight what you learned throughout the process. To score highly, make sure you explain the following:

  • Your approach to the creative process

    Talk about your own style of composing. Do you create a melody, words or a chord riff first? Everyone is different so explain your own process. 

  • Your changes or alterations to the compositions

    Include things that went wrong and what you left out as this is strong evidence of you thinking in a musically critical way. It is particularly good to see in a learning reflection task. In line with this, feel free to include the first drafts of an idea and chart how it changed into the final presented idea.

  • Your melodic, rhythmic and harmonic ideas

    Fully describe the melodic, rhythmic and harmonic ideas you used and show why you think they work. 

  • Your instrument

    Fully describe the instrument and effect choices you made. Again, you can talk about what you might have done first, what didn’t work and how you changed it. This highlights critical thinking.

  • Your work style

    Describe whether you prefer working on your own or in a group. What did you find were the benefits/drawbacks of each? 

  • Your future intentions

    Add a small note about your future intentions, for example, “in the future, when approaching a task like this, I would...”. This shows that genuine learning and reflection on that process has taken place and that you are now in a better position than when you started on your composing journey.

Final tips

To ensure you achieve a high descriptor, you should remember the following:

Final Tips

1
2
3
4
5

Seek advice

Seek advice from your teacher and others before you decide which two pieces to include. Sometimes the piece you prefer might not be the one that best showcases your creativity. Others might see more evidence of work and creativity in something you might not think has value.

1

Know the terminology

Use 'procedural knowledge' and appropriate musical terminology wherever possible but remember that graphic scores are equally valid here so don’t be afraid to be creative.

2

Outline your role

If you are composing as part of a group, make sure you outline what role your part plays in the overall composition.

3

Reflect

Spend a good part of your time on the section 'reflection on your learning'. This is a vital part of the CBA I process and the quality of this will affect the final descriptor you are awarded. Discuss the journey your compositions took, what mistakes you made and how you changed them. Also, look to the future and think about "what I will do in my future compositions after reflecting on what worked well or not so well for me". All evidence of critical learning awareness will get you a higher descriptor award.

Be proud

Finally, be positive! These are your works and your creations. You should be proud of them when presenting them. Do so with confidence and positivity.

Here are some final tips

for the Junior Cycle Music CBA 1.

Seek advice

Seek advice from your teacher and others before you decide which two pieces to include. Sometimes the piece you prefer might not be the one that best showcases your creativity. Others might see more evidence of work and creativity in something you might not think has value.

Know the terminology

Use 'procedural knowledge' and appropriate musical terminology wherever possible but remember that graphic scores are equally valid here so don’t be afraid to be creative.

Outline your role

If you are composing as part of a group, make sure you outline what role your part plays in the overall composition.

Reflect

Spend a good part of your time on the section 'reflection on your learning'. This is a vital part of the CBA I process and the quality of this will affect the final descriptor you are awarded. Discuss the journey your compositions took, what mistakes you made and how you changed them. Also, look to the future and think about "what I will do in my future compositions after reflecting on what worked well or not so well for me". All evidence of critical learning awareness will get you a higher descriptor award.

Be proud

Finally, be positive! These are your works and your creations. You should be proud of them when presenting them. Do so with confidence and positivity.

Hope these help - you got this!

By John Casey

John Casey is a secondary school teacher of Music with over 30 years of experience. He is very familiar with preparing students and correcting Music at the Junior cycle level.

Related subjects & topics
Explore similar posts in our community